Reply to comment on 'origins of the changing detector response in small megavoltage photon radiation fields'



Fenwick, John D, Georgiou, Georgios, Rowbottom, Carl G ORCID: 0000-0002-5716-6840, Underwood, Tracy SA and Kumar, Sudhir
(2018) Reply to comment on 'origins of the changing detector response in small megavoltage photon radiation fields'. PHYSICS IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY, 63 (19). 198002-.

[img] Text
Reply.docx - Author Accepted Manuscript

Download (173kB)

Abstract

Andreo and Benmakhlouf (2017 Phys. Med. Biol. 62 1518-32) have disputed a finding of Scott et al (2012 Phys. Med. Biol. 57 4461-76) that the variation with field-size of the response of small ion chambers and solid-state dosimeters in small megavoltage photon radiation fields can largely be attributed to density. Further evidence for this finding was provided by Fenwick et al (2018 Phys. Med. Biol. 63 125003), but Andreo and Benmakhlouf (2018 Phys. Med. Biol. 63 125003) have now challenged the methodology used in that study. Specifically, Andreo and Benmakhlouf suggest that mass stopping-powers of fictitious materials used in Monte Carlo radiation transport calculations should be adjusted with material density according to the polarization effect, as if the materials were real and created by compressing other real materials. In this reply, we observe that fictitious materials are not real, and therefore their densities, mass stopping-powers and microscopic radiation interaction cross-sections can be freely and independently chosen to provide the clearest answers to the questions being studied. And we note that the key role played by density in small field detector response was further confirmed by our group back in 2013, using fictitious materials in which mass stopping-powers were adjusted with density, as preferred by Andreo and Benmakhlouf, as well as being held fixed, with very similar results being obtained in both circumstances (Underwood et al 2013a Med. Phys. 40 082102).

Item Type: Article
Uncontrolled Keywords: small fields, detector response, density effect, stopping-power, Monte Carlo
Depositing User: Symplectic Admin
Date Deposited: 28 Sep 2018 07:22
Last Modified: 19 Jan 2023 01:15
DOI: 10.1088/1361-6560/aae0e4
Related URLs:
URI: https://livrepository.liverpool.ac.uk/id/eprint/3026822