Back to the bones: do muscle area assessment techniques predict functional evolution across a macroevolutionary radiation?

Bates, Karl ORCID: 0000-0002-0048-141X, Wang, Linjie, Dempsey, Matthew, Broyde, Sarah, Fagan, Michael and Cox, Phil (2021) Back to the bones: do muscle area assessment techniques predict functional evolution across a macroevolutionary radiation? Journal of the Royal Society Interface.

Text Manuscript_FINAL.pdf - Author Accepted Manuscript Access to this file is restricted: awaiting official publication and publisher embargo. Download (1MB)

Abstract

Measures of attachment or accommodation area on the skeleton are a popular means of rapidly generating estimates of muscle proportions and functional performance for use in large-scale macroevolutionary studies. Herein we provide the first evaluation of the accuracy of these muscle area assessment (MAA) techniques for estimating muscle proportions, force outputs and bone loading in a comparative macroevolutionary context using the rodent masticatory system as a case study. We find that MAA approaches perform poorly, yielding large absolute errors in muscle properties, bite force and particularly bone stress. Perhaps more fundamentally, these methods regularly fail to correctly capture many qualitative differences between rodent morphotypes, particularly in stress patterns in finite element models. These findings cast doubts on the validity of these approaches as means to provide input data for biomechanical models applied to understand functional transitions in the fossil record, and perhaps even in taxon-rich statistical models that examine broad-scale macroevolutionary patterns. We suggest that future work should go back to the bones to test if correlations between attachment area and muscle size within homologous muscles across a large number of species yield strong predictive relationships that could be used to deliver more accurate predictions for macroevolutionary and functional studies.

Item Type:	Article
Divisions:	Faculty of Health and Life Sciences Faculty of Health and Life Sciences > Institute of Life Courses and Medical Sciences
Depositing User:	Symplectic Admin
Date Deposited:	30 Jun 2021 15:07
Last Modified:	18 Jan 2023 21:37
URI:	https://livrepository.liverpool.ac.uk/id/eprint/3128279

Available Versions of this Item

• Back to the bones: do muscle area assessment techniques predict functional evolution across a macroevolutionary radiation? (deposited 30 Jun 2021 15:07) [Currently Displayed]
  • Back to the bones: do muscle area assessment techniques predict functional evolution across a macroevolutionary radiation? (deposited 21 Jul 2021 07:59)