A study to enhance medical students' professional decision-making, using teaching interventions on common medications

Wilcock, Jane and Strivens, Janet (2015) A study to enhance medical students' professional decision-making, using teaching interventions on common medications. MEDICAL EDUCATION ONLINE, 20 (1). 27097-.

Text 27097-162724-1-PB.pdf - Unspecified Download (381kB)

Abstract

Aim To create sustained improvements in medical students' critical thinking skills through short teaching interventions in pharmacology. Method The ability to make professional decisions was assessed by providing year-4 medical students at a UK medical school with a novel medical scenario (antenatal pertussis vaccination). Forty-seven students in the 2012 cohort acted as a pretest group, answering a questionnaire on this novel scenario. To improve professional decision-making skills, 48 students from the 2013 cohort were introduced to three commonly used medications, through tutor-led 40-min teaching interventions, among six small groups using a structured presentation of evidence-based medicine and ethical considerations. Student members then volunteered to peer-teach on a further three medications. After a gap of 8 weeks, this cohort (post-test group) was assessed for professional decision-making skills using the pretest questionnaire, and differences in the 2-year groups analysed. Results Students enjoyed presenting on medications to their peers but had difficulty interpreting studies and discussing ethical dimensions; this was improved by contextualising information via patient scenarios. After 8 weeks, most students did not show enhanced clinical curiosity, a desire to understand evidence, or ethical questioning when presented with a novel medical scenario compared to the previous year group who had not had the intervention. Students expressed a high degree of trust in guidelines and expert tutors and felt that responsibility for their own actions lay with these bodies. Conclusion Short teaching interventions in pharmacology did not lead to sustained improvements in their critical thinking skills in enhancing professional practice. It appears that students require earlier and more frequent exposure to these skills in their medical training.

Item Type:	Article
Uncontrolled Keywords:	critical thinking, professionalism, prescribing, antenatal pertussis vaccination, patient centredness, medical education
Subjects:	?? R1 ?? ?? RM ??
Depositing User:	Symplectic Admin
Date Deposited:	30 Oct 2015 09:53
Last Modified:	15 Dec 2022 15:24
DOI:	10.3402/meo.v20.27097
Related URLs:	Author Publisher
URI:	https://livrepository.liverpool.ac.uk/id/eprint/2034519